5.0 out of 5 stars Delicious, High Protein, Low Sugar Cereal

2026-02-21    -NICOLE C.

Magic Spoon is a delicious alternative to regular high sugar unhealthy cereals- if you're trying to stay away from sugar, and wanting high protein with low calories. Being a chocoholic, I love the Cocoa flavor. It reminds me of Cocoa Puffs, and is crunchy and filling. It doesn't get soggy in milk, and you're left with chocolate milk afterwards- just like the other unhealthy, sugary brands. Magic Spoon cereal is the best tasting high protein, low sugar cereal on the market, and well worth the higher cost!!

5.0 out of 5 stars Delicious, High Protein, Low Sugar Cereal

2026-01-04    -NICOLE C.

Magic Spoon is a delicious alternative to regular high sugar unhealthy cereals- if you're trying to stay away from sugar, and wanting high protein with low calories. Being a chocoholic, I love the Cocoa flavor. It reminds me of Cocoa Puffs, and is crunchy and filling. It doesn't get soggy in milk, and you're left with chocolate milk afterwards- just like the other unhealthy, sugary brands. Magic Spoon cereal is the best tasting high protein, low sugar cereal on the market, and well worth the higher cost!!

5.0 out of 5 stars 100% recomendable

2026-02-01    -Libeidy Sanchez

I’ve been wanting to try Magic Spoon for a long time. It’s got 13g of protein, 4g carbs, and 0 sugar. My favorite flavor was the chocolate chip cookie, but the taste does take a bit of getting used to. Definitely a healthy alternative to the cereals us Gen Xers grew up with.

5.0 out of 5 stars Tasty and healthy but a little pricey

2026-01-21    -Vanessa R. Harkins

I waited to try every flavor in this variety pack before leaving a review.Overall, this cereal is quite good. It's sweet but not too sweet and totally satisfies my sweet cravings without having to eat sugar. The only problem I have noticed is that some flavors initially don't have much taste, but then leave an aftertaste of what they are supposed to be. The texture is also a bit odd, but I don't mind it.Here are my thoughts on each individual flavor:Cinnamon Roll: Delicious. The smell alone is like walking into a bakery. The first mouthful was like a crunch bite of fresh cinnamon roll with thick icing.Fruity: Similar flavor to Froot Loops but it takes a moment for the flavor to register.Peanut butter: Pretty much tasteless. I only got a mild sensation of peanut butter flavor.Frosted: Like eating only the marshmallows from Lucky Charms.Cocoa: Tastes like dark chocolate but takes a moment to register. Some people may find it a little bitter, but it satisfied my chocolate cravings.Maple Waffle: Absolutely the best flavor by leaps and bounds! Just opening the box was like being hit with a wave of fresh waffles and syrup.

4.0 out of 5 stars Read the ingredients!

2026-01-08    -That One Guy

Please read all the ingredients before purchase. Pairs vary well with premium protein shakes for a little added sweetness without the sugar (Salted Caramel is my go to). Does not really taste that great in normal or unsweetened nut milk. I would completely stay away from chocolate chip i don't think anything could make that taste good 😬. I've bought it twice, all the other flavors are pretty solid. Very good for what it is.

5.0 out of 5 stars Packed with protein

2026-02-28    -MaxxiStaz

The media could not be loaded. When it comes to this cereal, I couldn't wait to try it because I loved eating cereal as a kid and I miss it now, but it's packed with too much sugar. When I first got the boxes, I was skeptical that the sugar total was actually 0. While reading the ingredients and nutritional content, I was surprised to find that this cereal was actually healthier than I had initially thought, based solely ong the reviews. It's so convenient to have on hand, especially when I want a late-night snack. I'm happy with the protein content because I rarely eat my daily amount, so this helps from the time I wake up. The fruity flavor is my favorite, and the chocolate chip cookie is a good one, too. I wish peanut butter had more peanut butter flavor in it, and as for cocoa, more of the winter cocoa flavor, like I'm drinking hot chocolate.

5.0 out of 5 stars Flavor variety appeal

2025-12-28    -Raven

Love the 4-pack sampler; Peanut Butter and Cocoa taste indulgent yet guilt-free at under 5g net carbs per serving, perfect for breakfast or snacks. Sweetened naturally without that fake aftertaste, and the portions are satisfying. Ideal for anyone ditching grains but craving cereal vibes.

5.0 out of 5 stars Packed with protein

2026-01-13    -MaxxiStaz

The media could not be loaded. When it comes to this cereal, I couldn't wait to try it because I loved eating cereal as a kid and I miss it now, but it's packed with too much sugar. When I first got the boxes, I was skeptical that the sugar total was actually 0. While reading the ingredients and nutritional content, I was surprised to find that this cereal was actually healthier than I had initially thought, based solely ong the reviews. It's so convenient to have on hand, especially when I want a late-night snack. I'm happy with the protein content because I rarely eat my daily amount, so this helps from the time I wake up. The fruity flavor is my favorite, and the chocolate chip cookie is a good one, too. I wish peanut butter had more peanut butter flavor in it, and as for cocoa, more of the winter cocoa flavor, like I'm drinking hot chocolate.

4.0 out of 5 stars Who knew cereal could be healthy AND tasty

2026-02-18    -Cameron

Mostly good!I love cereal but I’m trying to limit my sugar consumption, so when I saw this brand of healthy cereal I knew I had to try.I tried this one to sample the different flavors. I’m glad I did.Fruity - my favorite. Tastes similar to fruit loops.Peanut butter - meh, wouldn’t order again. It tastes like butterfinger w/o the sweetness. It tastes like protein powder. It tasted better dry than with milk.Frosted - pretty good. I would order again.Across the board the cereal sort of sticks to your teeth. Not a huge issue as many cereals do. But just wanted to point out.Also the texture of these cereals kind of remind me of the marshmellows in lucky charms.One side note is that the bags they come in are hard to open but easy to rip if that makes sense lol. Idk why they chose that particular plastic for the packaging.Overall I’m happy I ordered these! They are pricey, but I’d rather spend more on something healthy.I checked these in the Yuka app and all but the peanut butter one scored relatively high, I.e. they’re healthy!

3.0 out of 5 stars Good-but overpriced

2026-01-08    -Amy Crenshaw

This was my favorite cereal because it tastes good and it’s pretty healthy. Then the price spiked ridiculously high…it’s already a pretty small box to begin with. I can’t justify paying that much for cereal. No one should.